Blog & Newsroom

Is Your Employee Really an Independent Contractor? What you need to know in the eyes of the IRS

by | 26 Dec | Employee or Independent Contractor, IRS, Taxes - Corporate & Business

If your business uses independent contractors as part of its work force, depending on the circumstances, the IRS might reclassify these workers as employees. Such a reclassification would expose your business to employment taxes and penalties. In addition, your business might be responsible for retroactive fringe benefits for any reclassified workers.Business partners working on project, copyspace.jpeg

To avoid this possibility, we recommend that employers review every contract the business holds with an independent contractor together with their attorney or CPA. As advisors, we meet with our clients to review their contracts in light of the factors that the IRS considers in classifying workers as independent contractors or employees. Where necessary, we advise clients to reword the contract and meet with their legal counsel to reflect the working relationship.

Related read: Employee or Independent Contractor? Uber Case Sets Precedent

While a full discussion of the factors is beyond the scope of this article, a few examples follow:

  • Where the worker’s services are available to the general public, as well as the business, this usually indicates independent contractor Where the worker provides his services exclusively to the business, this generally indicates employee status.
  • Where the business does not have a general “at will” right to discharge the worker (that is, where the business is committed to use the worker for a set period of time or for a certain project), this generally indicates independent contractor status. Where the business can discharge a worker “at will”, this generally indicates employee status.
  • If a business requires a worker to perform services on the business premises, this generally indicates employee status. Where no such requirement exists, this may or may not indicate independent contractor status.
  • Payment by the hour, week, or month generally points to an employer-employee relationship, provided that this method of payment is not just a convenient way of paying an amount that was agreed upon as the cost of a job. Payment made by the job or on a straight commission generally indicates that the worker is an independent contractor.
  • If a business provides training to the worker, this generally indicates employee status. Where the business does not provide training to the worker, or hires the worker contemplating that the worker is already trained for the specific task, this generally indicates independent contractor status.

Is it time for you to review your business agreements with independent contractors? If you would like to meet and discuss the employee or independent contractor classification further, please contact us at info@zinnerco.com  or 216.831.0733. We’re ready to start the conversation and happy to help.

Since 1938, Zinner has counseled individuals and businesses from start-up to succession. At Zinner, we strive to ensure we understand your business and recognize threats that could impact your financial situation.
DOL Proposes New Independent Contractor Rule

What Employers and Workers Should Know The U.S. Department of Labor’s Wage and Hour Division announced a proposed rule intended to clarify when a worker is an employee and when the worker may be classified as an independent contractor under the Fair Labor Standards...

USPS Postmark Changes

A Tax Filing Risk Alert for Taxpayers For decades, many taxpayers have relied on a simple rule of thumb: if it is in the mail by the deadline, you are fine. However, recent U.S. Postal Service (USPS) clarification makes that assumption riskier. On Dec. 24, 2025, the...

Top Security Issues Tax Clients Must Watch Out for in 2026

Tax season has always been a prime opportunity for scammers, and 2026 is emerging as one of the most dangerous years yet. With increased filing confusion, AI‑powered fraud tactics, and a surge in data breaches fueling identity theft, tax clients need to be more...

Zinner & Co. Volunteers at Cleveland Food Bank Healthy Choice Market

On Jan. 22, Zinner & Co. employees spent the afternoon volunteering at the Greater Cleveland Food Bank’s Community Resource Center Healthy Choice Market. Our team was proud to support neighbors directly by helping make the shopping experience easier, more...

No Tax on Overtime Pay

The recently enacted One Big Beautiful Bill Act introduces a major change to the federal tax code, delivering welcome news for both employees and employers for tax years 2025 through 2028, as qualified overtime pay will not be subject to Federal income tax. This...

Send us your questions and we’ll share our insights with you on our blog!

Share Your Idea For 
A Zinner Blog Article